ASP.Net vs PHP

Started by Nicpoint45, 04-21-2010, 17:32:39

Previous topic - Next topic

Nicpoint45Topic starter

I have found some valuable facts regarding comparison between PHP and ASP.Net. I hope this will help a lot deciding between what to use for a professional web application development.

http://naspinski.net/post/AspNet-vs-php--speed-comparison.aspx

Looking forward to other people feedback.
  •  


Alex

It is like saying: Which car is faster: Honda Civic or Toyota Corolla on a road with posted speed limit of 100 km/hr ?

They are both good. Pick one, live happily ever after.
  •  


ravi

ASP is stand for active server pages...php is use for making new effective designs..................

ravi

#3
ASP.Net and PHP are both popular technologies used for web application development. However, there are some differences between them that you might consider when deciding which one to use for a professional web application development project.

ASP.Net is a web development framework developed by Microsoft. It is primarily used with the C# programming language and runs on the Windows operating system. ASP.Net offers a wide range of tools and features, making it a powerful choice for large-scale enterprise applications. It also has a strong integration with other Microsoft technologies.

On the other hand, PHP is a scripting language widely used for web development. It is open-source and runs on various platforms, including Windows, Linux, and macOS. PHP has a large and active community, providing extensive documentation and support. It is known for its simplicity and flexibility, making it a popular choice for small to medium-sized projects.

When deciding between the two, here are some factors to consider:

1. Performance: Both ASP.Net and PHP can deliver high-performance web applications. However, performance can vary depending on various factors, such as server configuration, code optimization, and caching techniques. It is essential to benchmark and evaluate performance based on your specific requirements.

2. Developer Experience: Consider the skills and familiarity of your development team. If they have experience with C# or the .NET framework, ASP.Net might be a more natural choice. Conversely, if they are experienced with PHP, it might make more sense to leverage their existing knowledge.

3. Ecosystem and Tooling: Evaluate the availability and quality of libraries, frameworks, and development tools for each technology. ASP.Net has a robust ecosystem supported by Microsoft, offering a wide range of tools and resources. PHP also has a vast ecosystem with numerous frameworks and libraries, thanks to its open-source nature.

4. Project Requirements: Consider the specific requirements of your web application. Certain features or integrations may be more readily available or better supported in one technology over the other. Assessing your project's functionality needs will help guide your decision.

5. Scalability: Both ASP.Net and PHP can handle scalable applications, but the approach may differ. ASP.Net provides features like caching, session state management, and load balancing that can aid in scaling applications. PHP also offers various scalability options, such as load balancing, database optimization, and caching mechanisms like Memcached or Redis.

6. Cost: Cost can be a significant consideration for professional web application development. ASP.Net is typically associated with licensing costs, as it requires Windows Server and may require purchasing additional Microsoft software. PHP, being open-source, is free to use, and you have a wider choice of hosting providers at different price points.

7. Community Support: Consider the size and activity of the respective communities for ASP.Net and PHP. PHP has a massive and vibrant community, with an extensive range of online resources, forums, and tutorials available. This can be advantageous for finding solutions to common issues or getting help when needed. ASP.Net also has a large community and benefits from official Microsoft support and documentation.

8. Integration with Third-Party Services: Evaluate how well ASP.Net or PHP integrate with the third-party services or APIs you plan to use in your web application. Both technologies have extensive integration capabilities, but it's essential to check if there are specific libraries or SDKs available for the services you require.

9. Security: Security is a critical aspect of web application development. Both ASP.Net and PHP offer security features and practices, but ASP.Net is often praised for its built-in security measures, such as request validation and authentication mechanisms. PHP, being a more open-source environment, may require additional caution and best practices to ensure secure coding.

10. Performance Optimization: Both ASP.Net and PHP provide techniques for optimizing performance, such as code profiling, database query optimization, and server-side caching. Consider the specific performance optimization features and tools available for each technology.

11. Hosting Options: Evaluate the availability and suitability of hosting options for ASP.Net and PHP. ASP.Net applications typically require Windows-based hosting, whereas PHP applications can run on various hosting platforms, including Linux-based ones.

12. Learning Curve: Consider the learning curve associated with each technology. ASP.Net, especially if you're using C#, may have a steeper learning curve for developers who are new to the Microsoft ecosystem. PHP, being simpler and widely adopted, may be easier for developers to pick up quickly.

13. Code Maintainability: Assess the maintainability of code written in each technology. PHP has a reputation for being more prone to spaghetti code due to its flexibility, whereas ASP.Net's strong typing and strict structure encourage cleaner code organization.

14. Available Talent Pool: Consider the availability of skilled developers for each technology in your desired location. Depending on your location and market, you may find a larger pool of PHP developers or ASP.Net developers.

15. Industry Adoption: Research the industry adoption and trends for each technology in your specific vertical. Understanding which technology is more widely used in your industry can provide insights into best practices, support, and future scalability.

16. Compatibility with Existing Systems: If you have existing systems or infrastructure, assess which technology integrates better with your current technology stack or can easily interface with existing databases, APIs, or services.

17. Learning Resources: Evaluate the availability and quality of learning resources, tutorials, documentation, and online communities for both ASP.Net and PHP. Accessible resources can greatly facilitate the learning process and troubleshooting.

18. Mobile App Development: Consider any plans for mobile app development alongside your web application. ASP.Net offers Xamarin, a cross-platform mobile app development framework, while PHP has frameworks like Laravel or Symfony that can be used in conjunction with other mobile development technologies.

19. Long-term Support and Updates: Check the long-term support and update plans for both ASP.Net and PHP. Consider the frequency of updates, bug fixes, security patches, and the overall commitment to maintaining the technology.

20. Future Scalability and Innovation: Evaluate the roadmap and future direction of both ASP.Net and PHP. Look for signs of ongoing development, new features, and community involvement, as this can indicate future scalability and the ability to leverage emerging technologies.

bidabingseo

Hi

ASP.NET is technology and PHP is a language but both are used to make websites,softwares etc.
so choose one with which you feel comfortable.

Thanks
newbielink:http://"http://www.promonu.com/index.php/services/merchant-accounts" [nonactive]
  •  


Vinil

1 Both are programming languages
2 Both follow OOPs
3 IDE is used on both
4 Both are different platforms
5 Both are used word wide and apps built in both asp.net and php
I dont understand what is the reason to compare the two?Who cares if asp.net has drag-and-drop feature while php lacks it .Posting problems and their solutions is the worth of forums


microsoftcygnet

Hello..
i think there are no such comparisons between these two..selection of programming platform totally depends on which kind of functionality u want with your application..
.Net development [nofollow]|E-Commerce [nofollow]
  •  

James Andy

ASP and PHP are both programming languages that are commonly used to create websites. Unlike the usual static html web pages, ASP and PHP websites are more dynamic and can allow users to interact and exchange information using the website's databases.


navkesh

The choice of technology is completely dependent on the requirements. The factors that influence the decision of choice are based on the following:

Complexity of Business logic
Density of contents
Expected number of Hits (if it is a website)
Budget
Size of project, etc.












ASP.NETPHPComments
Latest Stable Version4.05.3.3As of 19 Aug 2010
PriceASP.NET - .NET Framework is free. So ASP.NET also free
Web Server – IIS – Not Free. OS cost applicable
OS – Windows Server – Not Free
PHP – Free
Web Server – Free
OS – Linux is free, Windows is costly
PHP can be installed on any OS and Web server. But ASP.NET is recommended for IIS only (even though ports to few web servers available)
LicenseMS EULAPHP License v3.01
Third Party Hosting PriceCost involvedCost InvolvedBoth are not costly but if you compare, PHP is found to be a little bit cheaper
Promoted byMicrosoftPHP CommunityBoth are not costly but if you compare, PHP is found to be a little bit cheaper
PerformanceFasterFaster for small programs and slower for medium-to-big programsVery basic old argument – ASP.NET is compiled and PHP is interpreted (line by line compilation and execution)
Content Management SystemsDotNetNuke
SharePoint
N2CMS ...
Typo3
Joomla
Magento ...
Wide variety of options
LanguagesC#
VB.NET
Jscript, etc.
PHP
Some useful featuresWCF (Windows Communication Foundation), Web Service, .NET Remoting etc.
ASP.NET AJAX
Built-in Caching features
Web Service
Third party Ajax libraries
Third party Caching libraries


adelinebosanquet

There are so many comparitions between the ASP and PHP. The PHP is the open source and easy for the website development. but the ASP is advance and hard to website development.
newbielink:http://www.mobileiphonedevelopmentindia.com/iphone-application-development/iphone-application-development.html [nonactive]
  •