Seo Forum

Search Engine Optimization => Link Building => Topic started by: maddy58 on 11-18-2011, 04:50:44

Title: Is blog commenting effective in 2011 seo?
Post by: maddy58 on 11-18-2011, 04:50:44
Hello Experts,

I have one confusion regarding blog commenting. Is blog commenting effective in 2011 seo?

Thanks,



OsCommerce Development (http://www.seoranksmart.com/web-development/oscommerce-development.htm)
Title: Re: Is blog commenting effective in 2011 seo?
Post by: Smith Jones on 11-23-2011, 06:30:12
Hi there,

 In my opinion. Blog comments attract more unique visitor in your website. If the blog comment links contain do follow, it is more benefit in 2011 SEO.

Thanks a lot
Smith Jones   :-*
Title: Re: Is blog commenting effective in 2011 seo?
Post by: Hogward on 11-24-2011, 03:23:23
Every link has not equal value. Link in the blog post is very effective than the link in comment section. But quality comment on your niche blogs helps to drive traffic and improves search engine ranking.
Title: Re: Is blog commenting effective in 2011 seo?
Post by: MY on 12-13-2011, 05:59:53
it can be effective in terms of traffic. from an seo view it will give your website link diversity (assuming you use other methods to build links) and ths will look natural to search engines. in terms of PR you wont gain too much as header/footer links don't count for much as oppose to contextual links. also the high number of outbound links on the page dilute the PR weight that is given to linked sites. 
Title: Re: Is blog commenting effective in 2011 seo?
Post by: eurekapsycrille on 12-13-2011, 09:13:34
It has been as effect as before. But the hard thing about blog commenting is your comments must be approved first by the moderator or else it will be useless.
Title: Re: Is blog commenting effective in 2011 seo?
Post by: Merwin on 12-15-2011, 04:43:05
I guess blog commenting will always be helpful, since it attracts a lot of new visitors to the website.
Title: Re: Is blog commenting effective in 2011 seo?
Post by: bryanbell on 12-28-2011, 23:12:07
I think blog commenting is effective and helpful for traffic and ranking. But your comment is most relevant to blog which raise point of discussion to other people or blogger and if you get dofollow link from that particular blog than it is helpful to increase backlink of your website.
Title: Re: Is blog commenting effective in 2011 seo?
Post by: Altinkum Homes on 01-02-2012, 08:37:19
I guess it depends on whether you can find relevant good PR blogs to comment on. I've really struggled with that and don't find it a useful way to spend my time.
Title: Re: Is blog commenting effective in 2011 seo?
Post by: Dallas on 01-10-2012, 12:31:28
Perhaps only if the blog you are on has any relevancy to your website. If it has the same targeted keywords as the ones you are going for and it has a higher pagerank it could possibly benefit you.
Title: Re: Is blog commenting effective in 2011 seo?
Post by: AddisonTorres3047 on 01-26-2012, 07:23:41
Any link building technique is effective if you get good and quality backlinks and traffic. If you really want to know how much is blog commenting effective, just try it. This is the only way to find out, would it be really effective for your website.
Title: Re: Is blog commenting effective in 2011 seo?
Post by: martinwhisely on 01-27-2012, 03:58:06
As per my overview Blog comment help you to get increase your keyword ranking and page rank of the website. It mostly the edu and gov backlink which is very strong boost up your page rank of the website. If you do in relevant blogs then it will increase your visitor to your website and helpful for getting more sales conversion to your promoted product or services.
Title: Re: Is blog commenting effective in 2011 seo?
Post by: langergrp on 02-22-2012, 02:29:06
blog commenting is far too easy to attain backlinks, this is why google has really devalued the influence of the links in comments sections, they best place to try and get links is "above the fold" this mean links that are naturally visable without scrolling down the page. these are given the highest weighting and the highest clickthrough rate.

for a comment link to be elegable for a good chance of being a good link it needs to be one of the first comments on the post, as link juice is reduced the more times a link is seen, so the first link in a list is given slightly more weight than the last link in the list
Title: Re: Is blog commenting effective in 2011 seo?
Post by: Dennis Zocco on 08-12-2012, 19:24:11
Blog commenting is more effective if  the blog where you are in is popular and can easily crawled by search engines.This is my opinion.
Title: Re: Is blog commenting effective in 2011 seo?
Post by: RajSrivastav on 08-13-2012, 00:50:59
Yes, Blog commenting is still worth than Other submissions like article, Directory and Book marking. It is used to get indexed on search engines, passing link juice and useful to gain knowledge about your services.
Title: Re: Is blog commenting effective in 2011 seo?
Post by: sutha on 08-15-2012, 00:15:11
effective if the blog have Hight PR..besides that not effective
Title: Re: Is blog commenting effective in 2011 seo?
Post by: merlinraj on 09-28-2012, 00:57:05
Of course blog commenting is very important and effective also.The blog is fresh content and also to share the social media networks this also increase the page rank and traffic to our website.