Seo Forum

Directories => Other Directories => Topic started by: welshboy on 05-19-2010, 17:02:14

Title: Why are directories disliked by Google ?
Post by: welshboy on 05-19-2010, 17:02:14
I was on DP the other day and couldn't for the life of me figure out why everyone on there thinks that directories are hated by google and aren't good for the net.

I'm pretty new to webmastering so was hoping someone could shed some light on the history behind this sentiment ?
Title: Re: Why are directories disliked by Google ?
Post by: captaincaveman on 05-20-2010, 11:31:57
They're not disliked by Google, but people a couple of years ago got carried away with creating silly spammy directories that were all cross linking and passing link juice unnecessarily. Basically had loads of PR7 Link farms. All of them mostly got banned and since then only the best directories now exist.

It was good for the industry as it let all the crap sites dissappear...
Title: Re: Why are directories disliked by Google ?
Post by: ak47 on 05-21-2010, 11:38:59
Most directories take payment for inclusion and don't use rel="nofollow" which google recommeds all webmasters to do. They just don't want you selling link juice and to be quite frank that's what most directories were doing back then.

things have improved a little since then, but directories are still selling link juice just less so. People have now moved onto selling link juice from content sites and blogs were links can be hidden within text.

Title: Re: Why are directories disliked by Google ?
Post by: damponting44 on 10-13-2017, 00:44:47
Because of these Attributes of the Obviously Manipulative Directories . These aren't "hard and fast" rules - they're just common traits that many of the low quality directories seem to share. Google might take this move, along with some advice for anyone building a directory in the future.
Title: Re: Why are directories disliked by Google ?
Post by: RH-Calvin on 10-17-2017, 01:15:26
Directories are considered spam these days as Google states them as spam sites with very less content. Hence directory submissions are no more beneficial for ranking websites. These websites are rarely crawled and indexed in Google these days.
Title: Re: Why are directories disliked by Google ?
Post by: brookeroberts7 on 08-05-2020, 01:25:57
According to Moz research, web directories and local citations still appear to be a small ranking factor – especially for local businesses. However, Google's John Mueller himself has said that directory links “generally” don't help with SEO.