Photoshop Vs Gimp

Started by truffleshuffle, 05-02-2010, 23:06:33

Previous topic - Next topic

truffleshuffleTopic starter

Ok we're all web designers here and we've probably all dabbled in photoshop but what about GIMP. It's free and surprisingly powerful, anyone use it here ?

I have used it in the past and it's pretty darn impressive, it lacks some of the advanced features within photoshop but it's a great place to start for someone who can't afford PS.
  •  


mangoface

GIMP is open source right? I tried it last year when i first got into photoshop, it's not bad, I mean it caters for layers and has many of the same functionalities as photoshop but it's still so far behind and even with it's extensive plugin support it's still not considered a pro tool.

So although I really like it, I have to say you might as well just jump straight into photoshop as it's the only tool that most web designers take seriously!
  •  


Alex

#2
I use Photoshop.
It is free in Russia (certainly crаcked  :)))


Both Photoshop and GIMP are powerful image editing software tools that offer a wide range of features for designers and photographers. Here are some key points to consider when comparing Photoshop and GIMP:

1. Cost: Photoshop is a commercial software that requires a subscription to Adobe Creative Cloud, which can be quite expensive. On the other hand, GIMP is free and open-source, making it accessible to users who don't have the budget for Photoshop.

2. User Interface: Photoshop has a more polished and intuitive user interface compared to GIMP, which some users might find easier to navigate. GIMP's interface may seem less refined but can still be customized to suit individual preferences.

3. Feature Set: Photoshop offers a comprehensive set of advanced features for graphic design, photo manipulation, and retouching. It includes tools like content-aware fill, advanced masking options, and 3D editing capabilities. GIMP also provides a wide range of features, although some advanced functionalities in Photoshop may be missing or less developed in GIMP.

4. File Compatibility: Photoshop has better compatibility with various file formats, including proprietary Adobe formats. GIMP supports common file formats but may encounter issues when working with certain Photoshop-specific features or file types.

5. Community and Resources: Adobe Photoshop has a large and active community, along with extensive online resources, tutorials, and support. GIMP also has an active community that provides resources and support, although it may not be as extensive as Photoshop's community.

Ultimately, the choice between Photoshop and GIMP depends on your specific needs, budget, and experience level. For professionals and those requiring advanced features, Photoshop is often the preferred choice. However, GIMP can be a suitable alternative for beginners, hobbyists, or those looking for a free option.
  •  

Andrew11

I prefer Photoshops layout so much more, it is easier for a newbie to get started with photoshop as well as access to all of their tutorials.  GIMP I've noticed has a steep learning curve but is also free..there is a lot of customization you can download online for GIMP as well.
  •  

dathof

Man there is no question.. don't use such things as gimp .. just buy photoshop . Its the best . I have been using photoshop for 3 years and Im still using it.
  •  


wangyu

if you are going to working in the industry get photoshop as its unlikely to switch over anytime soon. If it's just personal then use whatever program your budget allows. You can also get Affinity Photo or GIMP ( free ) . I believe it would be adequate for most if not all your post-processing/editing needs.

whatever program you get, your still going to go through the same thing.

I prefer Gimp, as it is free to use, and you can still get professional results.

I am using the xp-pen star g640 ( https://www.xp-pen.com/product/51.html ) drawing pad for Gimp . It's the best thing I ever did for photo editing. It's seriously amazing. 
  •  

saravanan28

GIMP is a FREE image editing software whereas Photoshop is a PAID image editing software. ... GIMP contains fewer tools while Photoshop contains a lot of tools. You cannot use GIMP to edit pictures on the smartphone while Photoshop can be used to edit pictures on the smartphone.
  •  

Lishmalinyjames

GIMP is a FREE image editing software whereas Photoshop is a PAID image editing software. GIMP contains fewer tools while Photoshop contains a lot of tools. You cannot use GIMP to edit pictures on the smartphone while Photoshop can be used to edit pictures on the smartphone.


firstdigiadd

"If money isn't an issue, I would say stick with Photoshop. It's easier to learn, the user interface isn't that clunky, and allows for advanced editing.
GIMP is good, and the fact that it's free Photoshop will never beat. However, it cannot be compared to Photoshop in general."
  •